Contact us for a free appraisal or any questions. We’re happy to help!
Surprisingly Valuable Golden Age Horror Comics
When you're looking through a stack of old horror comics, how can you tell which ones are worth decent money?
First rule: earlier horror comics are worth more than later ones.
The reason is not their age, but the publisher's ability to shock and gross out readers was removed in the mid-1950s.
If you see the "Comics Code Authority" stamp on the cover (see example at right), then the comic you're looking at is not a so-called pre-Code horror comic.
The Code banned the use of certain words, images and concepts.
After the Code was introduced, for example, not only could comics not use the word "Zombie", but they couldn't show images of undead, explicit violence or sexual innuendo.
So comics WITHOUT this stamp were allowed to do more with their creative writing and art.
Second rule: if the cover makes you go "Ewww GROSS!" then the comic is worth far more.
Examples:
All these bizarre and gross-out concepts indicate that the comic you have found is worth SERIOUS money. These are the cream of Golden Age horror comics.
Of course, you might be totally lost and confused about what you have.
Never fear! We will confront the monsters under your bed or in your closet for you with a FREE comic book appraisal.
Click here to send us your list.
We also buy comic books for immediate cash!
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
These are examples of the average comics that most often show up in horror comic collections.
They are worth between $20 and $200 depending on condition.
Journey into Mystery #45
Uncanny Tales #51
Black Cat Mystic #58
Tales of Suspense #30
Strange Stories of Suspense #5
World of Mystery #1
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
Strange Tales #68
Tales of the Unexpected #3
Marvel Tales #143
Zaza the Mystic #11
Uncanny Tales #42
Tales of the Unexpected #5
These are definitely not the most valuable pre-Code horror comics, but they are better than average.
Most comics in this category do NOT have the Comics Code Authority stamp on their cover. They often feature skeletons, zombies, mummies, werewolves and other walking dead.
You can expect between $50 and $1,000 for this kind of comic, depending on what shape they are in.
Beware #16
Vault of Horror #33
Horrific #8
Witches Tales #27
Strange Mysteries #13
Weird Terror #2
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
Strange Mysteries #10
Horrific #5
Journey into Fear #14
The Vault of Horror #14
Journey into Mystery #9
Crime Mysteries #4
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
We didn't want to turn this into a list of the top 30 horror comics of the 1950s (click to see that list) or most valuable pre Code horror comics (the next 25 most valuable). You can look up the best of the best at those two pages.
The aim of this section is to demonstrate what the best in breed generally look like.
The more gruesome the cover the better. Injuries, stabbings, pieces of a person cut off, horrific interaction with the undead, torture, bondage, animal or insect attacks...
The prices vary so much for these. Typically they are worth AT LEAST $100 each, and the sky is the limit for the really good ones in great condition.
The Vault of Horror #19
Black Cat Mystery #40
Sensation Comics #109
Spellbound comic #4
Out of the Shadows #8
Spook Suspense and Mystery #28
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
Weird Chills #2
Mysterious Adventures #4
Ghostly Weird Stories #120
Dark Mysteries #7
the Unseen #14
Chamber of Chills #13
Mystic comics #24
Mister Mystery #14
Got comics, action figures, toys, statues, original art, LEGO or other collectibles?
We're buying! Click here to send us details of your collection and get it valued FREE.
Best Horror Comics of the 1950s
See which horror books from the late Golden Age are worth the most today.
Top Pre Code Horror Comics
More valuable horror comic books from the end of the Golden Age, before the Comics Code Authority spoiled the party.
EC Horror Comics Price Guides
See values for Tales from the Crypt, Vault of Horror, Haunt of Fear and many others.
Comics and Collectibles Near ME is buying Golden Age Horror Comics!